Waistpack recommendations?

Paul A. Steckler

I'm going to be doing a supported multi-day
tour late this summer, and I'd like to be able
to carry a few things, beyond what'll fit in
jersey pockets.

I've seen some waistpacks that are advertised as
suitable for biking. I don't want one of the
hydration models; I have a water bottle cage for
that.

Can anyone recommend a particular model of
waistpack?

-- Paul

Dan Daniel

On Mon, 3 May 2004 05:44:37 -0700, "Paul A. Steckler"
<steck@stecksoft.com> wrote:

>I'm going to be doing a supported multi-day
>tour late this summer, and I'd like to be able
>to carry a few things, beyond what'll fit in
>jersey pockets.
>
>I've seen some waistpacks that are advertised as
>suitable for biking. I don't want one of the
>hydration models; I have a water bottle cage for
>that.
>
>Can anyone recommend a particular model of
>waistpack?
>
>-- Paul
>

Have you thought about a handlebar bag instead? Much more convenient
and no worries about heat or rubbing.

carlfogel@comcast.net

On Mon, 3 May 2004 05:44:37 -0700, "Paul A. Steckler"
<steck@stecksoft.com> wrote:

>I'm going to be doing a supported multi-day
>tour late this summer, and I'd like to be able
>to carry a few things, beyond what'll fit in
>jersey pockets.
>
>I've seen some waistpacks that are advertised as
>suitable for biking. I don't want one of the
>hydration models; I have a water bottle cage for
>that.
>
>Can anyone recommend a particular model of
>waistpack?
>
>-- Paul
>

Dear Paul,

Many years ago, the same question about the best waist pack was
popular among U.S. trials riders. We also argued about whether it was
better to wear the pack in front or in back, an option not available
to people who pedal.

A visiting British expert saw our motley collection of waist packs,
shook his head, and pointed out that it made more sense to let the
motorcycle carry things rather than having ithem bouncing up and down
and chafing on our--

Well, he didn't call the waist packs because they actually tend to
hang a bit lower back there, don't they?

Ass-packs may make more sense than a knapsack when you're walking,
want to carry a few things, and may be taking them out and putting
them away frequently, but it usually makes more sense to use a frame,
seat, or handlebar bag to carry things on a bicycle.

If you still long for a fanny pack, get one with the widest belt and
biggest, ugliest zippers that you can find. Thin and medium belts are
no fun, and struggling with ordinary zippers clogged with dust and
sweat is frustrating.

Good luck,

Carl Fogel

Bill

"Paul A. Steckler" <steck@stecksoft.com> wrote in message
news:6YSdnQBYp9MJowvdRVn-gw@comcast.com...
> I'm going to be doing a supported multi-day
> tour late this summer, and I'd like to be able
> to carry a few things, beyond what'll fit in
> jersey pockets.
>
> I've seen some waistpacks that are advertised as
> suitable for biking. I don't want one of the
> hydration models; I have a water bottle cage for
> that.
>
> Can anyone recommend a particular model of
> waistpack?
>
> -- Paul
>
Go to a outdoor/camping store and try them on. It needs to be big enough.
The waist belt needs to be wide enough to be comfortable. Try various models
sitting in a chair bent over as you would be positioned on a bike. You don't
want a fastening device that ends up in an uncomfortable location. I have
one I have used for years when I need to take a little extra stuff and when
the weather means significant layer changes during the day.
What I'm using is similar to this:
http://www.mec.ca/Products/product_...D=1083605254948
Bill Brannon

Shawn Amir

Try http://www.jandd.com/ for their medium fanny pack. They have them in
the "sale items" section for $19. The medium packs have a wide support area
that makes them quite comfortable despite the large capacity.

Cheers, Shawn

S. Anderson

<carlfogel@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:i6uc90lsmecjrgbl6vn1nqrenphp0p5175@4ax.com...
> Ass-packs may make more sense than a knapsack when you're walking,
> want to carry a few things, and may be taking them out and putting
> them away frequently, but it usually makes more sense to use a frame,
> seat, or handlebar bag to carry things on a bicycle.

I'll agree that it's aggravating wearing a fanny sack (I wear one..) for
several reasons. However, the biggest argument against a bag mounted on the
bike (at least, ATB's anyway..) is that they rattle like there's a 6.9
earthquake going on and you're stuck in a cutlery store!!! If you decide on
a bike mounted bag, prepare to stuff it with rags and junk to shut up all
the crap clattering around in there.

My $0.02 worth..

Scott..

carlfogel@comcast.net

On Mon, 3 May 2004 17:00:01 -0400, "S. Anderson"
<scott.anderson3@zsympaticoz.ca> wrote:

><carlfogel@comcast.net> wrote in message
>news:i6uc90lsmecjrgbl6vn1nqrenphp0p5175@4ax.com...
>> Ass-packs may make more sense than a knapsack when you're walking,
>> want to carry a few things, and may be taking them out and putting
>> them away frequently, but it usually makes more sense to use a frame,
>> seat, or handlebar bag to carry things on a bicycle.
>
>I'll agree that it's aggravating wearing a fanny sack (I wear one..) for
>several reasons. However, the biggest argument against a bag mounted on the
>bike (at least, ATB's anyway..) is that they rattle like there's a 6.9
>earthquake going on and you're stuck in a cutlery store!!! If you decide on
>a bike mounted bag, prepare to stuff it with rags and junk to shut up all
>the crap clattering around in there.
>
>My $0.02 worth..
>
>Scott..
>

Dear Scott,

Loose things rattle in bags, whether strapped to frames or fannies. In
any case, a rag isn't the worst thing to have handy when fixing a
bicycle on a hot day or in a rainstorm.

You might better object to the paint damage from a bag's straps.

Carl Fogel

S. Anderson

<carlfogel@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:70kd9052ef6ias1reuat7hhtsqc0ddigcr@4ax.com...
> Dear Scott,
>
> Loose things rattle in bags, whether strapped to frames or fannies. In
> any case, a rag isn't the worst thing to have handy when fixing a
> bicycle on a hot day or in a rainstorm.
>
> You might better object to the paint damage from a bag's straps.
>
> Carl Fogel

I used to use the underseat contraption. I had a rag in there trying to
quiet the cacaphony but it eventually drove me insane, hence my present
state of affairs. ;-) It still rattles a bit around my Michelin pneu, but
it seems to be once degree removed from the vibration, on a "liquid damper"
system. And you're absolutely right, the rag is dang handy. No complaints
there.

Cheers,

Scott..

Frank Krygowski

Dan Daniel wrote:

>
> Have you thought about a handlebar bag instead? Much more convenient
> and no worries about heat or rubbing.

My thoughts exactly. Or alternately, a good-sized saddlebag.

Why would you want something hanging on your body, chafing you and
soaking you with your sweat?

--
-------------
Frank Krygowski [To reply, remove rodent and vegetable dot com,
replace with cc.ysu dot edu]

------------ And now a word from our sponsor ------------------
For a quality usenet news server, try DNEWS, easy to install,
fast, efficient and reliable. For home servers or carrier class
installations with millions of users it will allow you to grow!
---- See http://netwinsite.com/sponsor/sponsor_dnews.htm ----

Pat

> I'm going to be doing a supported multi-day
> tour late this summer, and I'd like to be able
> to carry a few things, beyond what'll fit in
> jersey pockets.
>
> I've seen some waistpacks that are advertised as
> suitable for biking. I don't want one of the
> hydration models; I have a water bottle cage for
> that.
>
> Can anyone recommend a particular model of
> waistpack?
>
> -- Paul

Okay. get this one and take out the water bladder:
http://www.hydrapak.com/PACKS/pop.html?pack=hipSip70

I like it because it hangs down kinda low on my hips (not directly on my
waist) when loaded with water. It's roomy and the belt part is extremely
sturdy.

Pat in TX
>
>

Paul A. Steckler

"Frank Krygowski" <frkrygow@mousepotato.com> wrote in message
news:409705ed@news.ysu.edu...
> Dan Daniel wrote:
>
> >
> > Have you thought about a handlebar bag instead? Much more convenient
> > and no worries about heat or rubbing.
>
> My thoughts exactly. Or alternately, a good-sized saddlebag.

I have a Topeak handlebar bag on my other bike, which I quite like.

However, the fat bar on my road bike won't accept the Topeak mount
clip -- I tried.

So I need some other means of carrying things.

-- Paul

Tom Keats

In article <409705ed@news.ysu.edu>,
Frank Krygowski <frkrygow@mousepotato.com> writes:
> Dan Daniel wrote:
>
>>
>> Have you thought about a handlebar bag instead? Much more convenient
>> and no worries about heat or rubbing.
>
> My thoughts exactly. Or alternately, a good-sized saddlebag.
>
> Why would you want something hanging on your body, chafing you and
> soaking you with your sweat?

I guess it's easy to take stealable stuff with you, after
parking the bike to go into a store or something.

Last summer I met my next-door neighbour at the green grocer's
down the street; he was stuffing an entire watermelon (big one)
into his backpack for the ride home. I thought he was tempting
Murphy's Law a bit too much, but he made it home okay.

I hate packing stuff on me, when there's a whole bike to load
it on. But I guess it boils down to personal preference. And
a fanny pack (or a handlebar bag for that matter) ain't a
backpack with a huge watermelon in it.

But I figure a handlebar bag might be more accessible on the
fly than a waistpack. And if it's easily detachable, it should
be just as convenient to pack around off-bike. Plus there's the
benefit of route sheet/map holders on the handlebar bag's lid.

I just had a thought -- I wonder if the Original Poster might
find something that best meets his requirements at an army
surplus store? Something to investigate, anyway.


cheers,
Tom


--
-- Powered by FreeBSD
Above address is just a spam midden.
I'm really at: tkeats [curlicue] vcn [point] bc [point] ca

Roger Zoul

Paul A. Steckler wrote:
:: I'm going to be doing a supported multi-day
:: tour late this summer, and I'd like to be able
:: to carry a few things, beyond what'll fit in
:: jersey pockets.
::
:: I've seen some waistpacks that are advertised as
:: suitable for biking. I don't want one of the
:: hydration models; I have a water bottle cage for
:: that.
::
:: Can anyone recommend a particular model of
:: waistpack?

Get on of those bags that fits on the top tube....mine has compartments on
either side...so I put my garage door opener on one side, along with my
mobile phone, keys, and on the other side I put some food and paper towels.
Still plenty of room left, too.

David Kerber

In article <1oc77c.ari.ln@bud.garden.local>, tomk2003@hotmail.com
says...

....

> I hate packing stuff on me, when there's a whole bike to load
> it on. But I guess it boils down to personal preference. And
> a fanny pack (or a handlebar bag for that matter) ain't a
> backpack with a huge watermelon in it.
>
> But I figure a handlebar bag might be more accessible on the
> fly than a waistpack. And if it's easily detachable, it should
> be just as convenient to pack around off-bike. Plus there's the
> benefit of route sheet/map holders on the handlebar bag's lid.

Do you know of any handlebar bags which hang low enough to fit under
aero bars? I like the aero bars on my tourer, but haven't located a
handlebar bag which will work with them.

.....

--
Remove the ns_ from if replying by e-mail (but keep posts in the
newsgroups if possible).