Cycling and bicycle racing discussion forums.   View New Forum Topics
Today's Forum Topics

Set as homepage


Go Back   Cycling Forums > Tech Corner > Power Training
User Name
Password
Register FAQ Members List Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read


Welcome to CyclingForums.com

You are currently viewing our website as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions. You will have to register before you can post to this thread.

By joining our free online community you will have access to post new topics, communicate privately with other cyclingforums.com members (PM), respond to polls, upload photos and access other special features like product reviews and classifieds.


Poll: What's your Functional Threshold power?

Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Old 01-09.-2006, 01:21 PM   #196
Macey
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 13
Default Re: Poll: What's your Functional Threshold power?

Quote:
Originally Posted by K50
A guy on my team just won a 40km TT, and his time was 47 minutes. He's only Cat3. The day after that, he also did a 4 man TT race and came in third place. I think that might move him up to Cat 1... unless road racing is really tough where I live.

K50,

Are you sure the 40 km TT was really 40 km? Was it a closed loop? (no downhill or tailwind all the way)

That average speed is fast enough to win the last _world_ time trial championship. Or the one before that. Or the one before that (even including Millar, with drugs). By a goodish margin too. Check the numbers - I would be more inclined to believe a time of 57 minutes if he is cat 3 and it is a local TT race. (or there's been a helluva wind shift part way through his run)

Dan
Macey is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 03-09.-2006, 05:00 AM   #197
bigbevans
Registered User
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 59
Default Re: Poll: What's your Functional Threshold power?

I think FT is not something that is easy to measure and there are a lot of vague measurements and this make comparison difficult. There seem to be several ways that people measure it making this a bit of a lottery not a comparision.
bigbevans is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 03-09.-2006, 08:05 AM   #198
RapDaddyo
Registered User
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Las Vegas, NV
Posts: 4,115
Default Re: Poll: What's your Functional Threshold power?

Quote:
Originally Posted by bigbevans
I think FT is not something that is easy to measure and there are a lot of vague measurements and this make comparison difficult. There seem to be several ways that people measure it making this a bit of a lottery not a comparision.
Actually, FTP is precisely defined (maximum sustainable constant power for 60mins). It's just that people "estimate" their FTP using various methods rather than doing a 60 min max power test ride.
RapDaddyo is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 03-09.-2006, 08:24 AM   #199
otb4evr
Registered User
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Chicagoland
Posts: 323
Default Re: Poll: What's your Functional Threshold power?

Quote:
Originally Posted by RapDaddyo
Actually, FTP is precisely defined (maximum sustainable constant power for 60mins). It's just that people "estimate" their FTP using various methods rather than doing a 60 min max power test ride.
I think you would have huge discrepancies here, also, due to motivation...

Besides, just because someone has a higher FTP than you doesn't mean that they are faster than you...

I think this is something that you witnessed personally, right RDO?

otb4evr is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 03-09.-2006, 11:59 AM   #200
RapDaddyo
Registered User
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Las Vegas, NV
Posts: 4,115
Default Re: Poll: What's your Functional Threshold power?

Quote:
Originally Posted by otb4evr
I think you would have huge discrepancies here, also, due to motivation...
Absolutely. But, I think a lot of people who are using their 20min interval power as their FTP are placing a huge bet on motivation and I think they are often disappointed.

Quote:
Originally Posted by otb4evr
Besides, just because someone has a higher FTP than you doesn't mean that they are faster than you...

I think this is something that you witnessed personally, right RDO?

Absolutely! Hell, I witness it every day. We have this 120lb 20-y.o. kid in my club (Chuck) and I know that every time we do a long climb that I need 75-100W more power to stay with him. But, it's fun trying anyway.
RapDaddyo is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 03-09.-2006, 12:52 PM   #201
otb4evr
Registered User
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Chicagoland
Posts: 323
Default Re: Poll: What's your Functional Threshold power?

Quote:
Originally Posted by RapDaddyo
Absolutely. But, I think a lot of people who are using their 20min interval power as their FTP are placing a huge bet on motivation and I think they are often disappointed.
I agree with you, but they are only hurting themselves...

This isn't a "my dad can beat up your dad" contest...

The way that I took this post was a chance to see what other people could do FTP-wise.

Honestly, none of it really matters when the rubber meets the road, though.

For example, look at the times that are posted. There are some blazing times with what could be looked at as moderate wattage numbers.

One of the things this proves is that there is more to winning bike races than how much wattage you can put out...

I just consider training with wattage as a way to quantify training and analyze racing.

When it all comes down to it, anyone can put in any number they want in this chart and it doesn't matter to me. The only numbers that matter to me are mine...

Jim
otb4evr is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 06-09.-2006, 04:06 AM   #202
bspurgeon
Registered User
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 11
Default Re: Poll: What's your Functional Threshold power?

ID FT Wt. W/Kg 10m(16km) 25m(40km)

the holster 370 67 5.52
Camoscio 340 62 5.48
scotmart 385 72 5.35 19:58 (47:21 on a 37.8km course)
musher 340 64 5.31
bigmatt 396 75 5.28
BullGod 365 70 5.21
whoawhoa 320 62.5 5.12
gvanwagner 325 64 5.08
joemw 340 69 4.92
musher 318 65 4.89
gonzalovilaseca 310 68 4.56
kennethn 320 70.3 4.55
JohnMeyers 350 77 4.54
PSUCycling 305 68 4.48 (40k 58:30 @ 250W ave-asthema!)
peterpen 290 65 4.46
zaskar 280 63 4.44
joule 266 60 4.43
HammerHead 300 68 4.41
bikeguy 315 72 4.38 5 km rolling TT, 7:15; standard, no aero bars, after 90k
rouleur 315 72 4.38
Thorman 340 78 4.36
Lazy Llama 286 66 4.33 13.3 mi TT, 30:12
dshep27283 345 80 4.31
postal_bag 325 76 4.28
pledac 295 69 4.27
RobM 312 73 4.27
mattv2099 314 75 4.19
Stanette 313 75 4.17
Atsic 252 61 4.13
yzfrr11 310 75 4.13
Xav 318 77 4.13
Spunout 280 68 4.12
RapDaddyo 325 80 4.06
jbvcoaching 310 77 4.03 21:10 52:17
velobob 310 77 4.03
jack.hutchinson 285 71 4.01
bspurgeon 315 78.5 3.99
K50 275 69 3.99, (no TT's) all XC baby!
cube 290 73 3.97
Old Junker 250 63 3.97
velomanct 310 79 3.92
My02Sti 305 79 3.86
Otb4evr 385 100 3.85 22:19 58:48
BlueJersey 230 60 3.83
robkit 280 75 3.73
sugaken 240 66 3.64
amartinez 242 67 3.61
woodgab 321 89 3.61
bigbevans 260 73 3.56 21:30 (270 w) 56:46
Hookyrider 284 80 3.55
Krazyderek 260 78 3.33
AndROOb 232 71 3.27
spomanski 310 96 3.23
netscriber 143 47 3.04
beerco 220 78 2.82
fmarques25 204 74 2.76
the holster 180 67 2.69
bspurgeon is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 13-09.-2006, 09:19 AM   #203
K50
Registered User
 
K50's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Calgary, Canada
Posts: 271
Default Re: Poll: What's your Functional Threshold power?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Macey
K50,

Are you sure the 40 km TT was really 40 km? Was it a closed loop? (no downhill or tailwind all the way)

That average speed is fast enough to win the last _world_ time trial championship. Or the one before that. Or the one before that (even including Millar, with drugs). By a goodish margin too. Check the numbers - I would be more inclined to believe a time of 57 minutes if he is cat 3 and it is a local TT race. (or there's been a helluva wind shift part way through his run)

Dan

I have no idea what the circumstances are on the race. I want to look into it though, because I'm really curious... But it was indeed a "40km" TT and his time was 47 minutes...not sure how close to 40km it was and where the race was held, but yeah when I saw that, I nearly crapped myself. That's a blazing fast time!!! And maybe there was a wicked wind there too.
__________________
Kev
K50 is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 15-09.-2006, 12:15 AM   #204
Markster
Registered User
 
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 81
Default Re: Poll: What's your Functional Threshold power?

ID FT Wt. W/Kg 10m(16km) 25m(40km)

the holster 370 67 5.52
Camoscio 340 62 5.48
scotmart 385 72 5.35 19:58 (47:21 on a 37.8km course)
musher 340 64 5.31
bigmatt 396 75 5.28
BullGod 365 70 5.21
whoawhoa 320 62.5 5.12
gvanwagner 325 64 5.08
joemw 340 69 4.92
musher 318 65 4.89
Markster 335 70 4.79 19:57 51:55
gonzalovilaseca 310 68 4.56
kennethn 320 70.3 4.55
JohnMeyers 350 77 4.54
PSUCycling 305 68 4.48 (40k 58:30 @ 250W ave-asthema!)
peterpen 290 65 4.46
zaskar 280 63 4.44
joule 266 60 4.43
HammerHead 300 68 4.41
bikeguy 315 72 4.38 5 km rolling TT, 7:15; standard, no aero bars, after 90k
rouleur 315 72 4.38
Thorman 340 78 4.36
Lazy Llama 286 66 4.33 13.3 mi TT, 30:12
dshep27283 345 80 4.31
postal_bag 325 76 4.28
pledac 295 69 4.27
RobM 312 73 4.27
mattv2099 314 75 4.19
Stanette 313 75 4.17
Atsic 252 61 4.13
yzfrr11 310 75 4.13
Xav 318 77 4.13
Spunout 280 68 4.12
RapDaddyo 325 80 4.06
jbvcoaching 310 77 4.03 21:10 52:17
velobob 310 77 4.03
jack.hutchinson 285 71 4.01
bspurgeon 315 78.5 3.99
K50 275 69 3.99, (no TT's) all XC baby!
cube 290 73 3.97
Old Junker 250 63 3.97
velomanct 310 79 3.92
My02Sti 305 79 3.86
Otb4evr 385 100 3.85 22:19 58:48
BlueJersey 230 60 3.83
robkit 280 75 3.73
sugaken 240 66 3.64
amartinez 242 67 3.61
woodgab 321 89 3.61
bigbevans 260 73 3.56 21:30 (270 w) 56:46
Hookyrider 284 80 3.55
Krazyderek 260 78 3.33
AndROOb 232 71 3.27
spomanski 310 96 3.23
netscriber 143 47 3.04
beerco 220 78 2.82
fmarques25 204 74 2.76
the holster 180 67 2.69
Markster is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 15-09.-2006, 04:14 AM   #205
joemw
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: SoCal
Posts: 97
Default Re: Poll: What's your Functional Threshold power?

ID FT Wt. W/Kg 10m(16km) 25m(40km)

the holster 370 67 5.52
Camoscio 340 62 5.48
scotmart 385 72 5.35 19:58 (47:21 on a 37.8km course)
musher 340 64 5.31
bigmatt 396 75 5.28
BullGod 365 70 5.21
joemw 354 68 5.20
whoawhoa 320 62.5 5.12
gvanwagner 325 64 5.08
musher 318 65 4.89
Markster 335 70 4.79 19:57 51:55
gonzalovilaseca 310 68 4.56
kennethn 320 70.3 4.55
JohnMeyers 350 77 4.54
PSUCycling 305 68 4.48 (40k 58:30 @ 250W ave-asthema!)
peterpen 290 65 4.46
zaskar 280 63 4.44
joule 266 60 4.43
HammerHead 300 68 4.41
bikeguy 315 72 4.38 5 km rolling TT, 7:15; standard, no aero bars, after 90k
rouleur 315 72 4.38
Thorman 340 78 4.36
Lazy Llama 286 66 4.33 13.3 mi TT, 30:12
dshep27283 345 80 4.31
postal_bag 325 76 4.28
pledac 295 69 4.27
RobM 312 73 4.27
mattv2099 314 75 4.19
Stanette 313 75 4.17
Atsic 252 61 4.13
yzfrr11 310 75 4.13
Xav 318 77 4.13
Spunout 280 68 4.12
RapDaddyo 325 80 4.06
jbvcoaching 310 77 4.03 21:10 52:17
velobob 310 77 4.03
jack.hutchinson 285 71 4.01
bspurgeon 315 78.5 3.99
K50 275 69 3.99, (no TT's) all XC baby!
cube 290 73 3.97
Old Junker 250 63 3.97
velomanct 310 79 3.92
My02Sti 305 79 3.86
Otb4evr 385 100 3.85 22:19 58:48
BlueJersey 230 60 3.83
robkit 280 75 3.73
sugaken 240 66 3.64
amartinez 242 67 3.61
woodgab 321 89 3.61
bigbevans 260 73 3.56 21:30 (270 w) 56:46
Hookyrider 284 80 3.55
Krazyderek 260 78 3.33
AndROOb 232 71 3.27
spomanski 310 96 3.23
netscriber 143 47 3.04
beerco 220 78 2.82
fmarques25 204 74 2.76
joemw is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 29-09.-2006, 02:59 AM   #206
cadence230
Registered User
 
cadence230's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Springfield, Missouri, USA
Posts: 51
Default Re: Poll: What's your Functional Threshold power?

ID FT Wt. W/Kg 10m(16km) 25m(40km)

the holster 370 67 5.52
Camoscio 340 62 5.48
scotmart 385 72 5.35 19:58 (47:21 on a 37.8km course)
musher 340 64 5.31
bigmatt 396 75 5.28
BullGod 365 70 5.21
joemw 354 68 5.20
whoawhoa 320 62.5 5.12
gvanwagner 325 64 5.08
musher 318 65 4.89
Markster 335 70 4.79 19:57 51:55
gonzalovilaseca 310 68 4.56
kennethn 320 70.3 4.55
JohnMeyers 350 77 4.54
PSUCycling 305 68 4.48 (40k 58:30 @ 250W ave-asthema!)
peterpen 290 65 4.46
zaskar 280 63 4.44
joule 266 60 4.43
HammerHead 300 68 4.41
bikeguy 315 72 4.38 5 km rolling TT, 7:15; standard, no aero bars, after 90k
rouleur 315 72 4.38
Thorman 340 78 4.36
Lazy Llama 286 66 4.33 13.3 mi TT, 30:12
dshep27283 345 80 4.31
postal_bag 325 76 4.28
pledac 295 69 4.27
RobM 312 73 4.27
cadence230 280 4.24
mattv2099 314 75 4.19
Stanette 313 75 4.17
Atsic 252 61 4.13
yzfrr11 310 75 4.13
Xav 318 77 4.13
Spunout 280 68 4.12
RapDaddyo 325 80 4.06
jbvcoaching 310 77 4.03 21:10 52:17
velobob 310 77 4.03
jack.hutchinson 285 71 4.01
bspurgeon 315 78.5 3.99
K50 275 69 3.99, (no TT's) all XC baby!
cube 290 73 3.97
Old Junker 250 63 3.97
velomanct 310 79 3.92
My02Sti 305 79 3.86
Otb4evr 385 100 3.85 22:19 58:48
BlueJersey 230 60 3.83
robkit 280 75 3.73
sugaken 240 66 3.64
amartinez 242 67 3.61
woodgab 321 89 3.61
bigbevans 260 73 3.56 21:30 (270 w) 56:46
Hookyrider 284 80 3.55
Krazyderek 260 78 3.33
AndROOb 232 71 3.27
spomanski 310 96 3.23
netscriber 143 47 3.04
beerco 220 78 2.82
fmarques25 204 74 2.76
cadence230 is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 30-09.-2006, 11:04 AM   #207
joule
Registered User
 
joule's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 212
Default Re: Poll: What's your Functional Threshold power?

Best effort for 40k TT 2006:
- Joule, 261 watts (avg), 60 kg, 4.35 w/kg, 40km (25.85 mi)
joule is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 09-10.-2006, 01:32 AM   #208
POGATA
Registered User
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 255
Default Re: Poll: What's your Functional Threshold power?

Quote:
Originally Posted by beerco
Future TdF or World TT champ? What's his name?
He should`ve won ProTour races this year, w/kg=6,854, if it`s true, he`s number ONE!

POGATA is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 09-10.-2006, 01:52 AM   #209
POGATA
Registered User
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 255
Default Re: Poll: What's your Functional Threshold power?

Quote:
Originally Posted by RapDaddyo
Actually, FTP is precisely defined (maximum sustainable constant power for 60mins). It's just that people "estimate" their FTP using various methods rather than doing a 60 min max power test ride.


Hunter Allens defintion
POGATA is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 09-10.-2006, 02:17 AM   #210
POGATA
Registered User
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 255
Default Re: Poll: What's your Functional Threshold power?

Quote:
Originally Posted by whoawhoa
So, if you're a super freak (cough cough... Nathan O'Neil...cough cough) and a 40k may only take you 45 odd minutes, do you use that for FT, or adjust to 1-hr?


He`s not very impressive!
POGATA is offline  
Reply With Quote

Reply


Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump



All times are GMT +10. The time now is 05:33 AM.


Powered by: vBulletin Copyright © 2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2001 - 2006 cyclingforums.com

Links to websites we like:
Pezcyclingnews | Cyclingnews.com | Wine Zone | iinet