Cycling and bicycle racing discussion forums.   View New Forum Topics
Today's Forum Topics

Set as homepage


Go Back   Cycling Forums > Bike Racing > Grand Tours - Giro - Tour de France - Vuelta a España
User Name
Password
Register FAQ Members List Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read


Welcome to CyclingForums.com

You are currently viewing our website as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions. You will have to register before you can post to this thread.

By joining our free online community you will have access to post new topics, communicate privately with other cyclingforums.com members (PM), respond to polls, upload photos and access other special features like product reviews and classifieds.


Zabriskie is a disgrace to Americans in the international peleton

Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Old 08-07.-2005, 05:43 AM   #46
rejobako
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Posts: 648
Default Re: Zabriskie is a disgrace to Americans in the international peleton

Quote:
Originally Posted by homeycheese
I went back and looked and in the Tuesday morning edition of the USA Today was a brief comment and profile on DZ in which Riis questioned DZ's peloton riding skills.

I'd say that was quite foreboding.

As for DZ being a disgrace, BS. The peloton has a way of dispensing justice and will take care of that issue.

The real disgrace is investing time and money in a rider and then abandoing him and the yellow jersey when you have used him up. Riis has shown his true colors, win at all costs, screw the rider, screw the respect for the Yellow Jersey. DZ was the only one exhibiting class with his solo ride to the line. Riis and the team should hang their heads in shame. Not one went back down the line to check on DZ and that is disgraceful.

Paul Sherwan offered similar (not quite so damning) sentiments, saying that he thought it would have been appropriate for at least one or two of his CSC teammates to hang back and shepherd DZ home.

But it's awfully easy to second-guess in this kind of situation, when in real time the decision needed to be made without hesitation. The reports I heard were that Riis and his team discussed what to do if DZ had a problem late in the stage, and the decision was to leave him and go for the sponsor's main goal of winning the TTT and also to minimize any GC impact on Basso. When the incident happened, CSC could, in theory, have pre-assigned a couple of riders to stay with DZ and send the rest to the line, but they would have had to be doubly sure they had the minimum 5 riders get to the line to stop the clock. Given the stress and excitement of that unfortunate moment, it seems unfair to condemn Riis and his team so harshly.
rejobako is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 08-07.-2005, 05:48 AM   #47
DiabloScott
Registered User
 
DiabloScott's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Mt. Diablo, California
Posts: 2,249
Default Re: Zabriskie is a disgrace to Americans in the international peleton

Quote:
Originally Posted by rejobako
...

Given the stress and excitement of that unfortunate moment, it seems unfair to condemn Riis and his team so harshly.


If it were Team Discovery and they had Hincapie in yellow and didn't wait for him you can bet you'd have heard a lot of condemnations. Disgraceful, scandalous, etc.
__________________


http://diabloscott.blogspot.com
DiabloScott is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 08-07.-2005, 05:59 AM   #48
rejobako
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Posts: 648
Default Re: Zabriskie is a disgrace to Americans in the international peleton

Quote:
Originally Posted by DiabloScott
If it were Team Discovery and they had Hincapie in yellow and didn't wait for him you can bet you'd have heard a lot of condemnations. Disgraceful, scandalous, etc.

LOL; Agreed. A half-dozen "Lance is the Antichrist" threads would have popped up simultaneously, followed soon by allegations that Armstrong intentionally ordered Hincapie to fall to have an excuse for losing a tight TTT.
rejobako is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 08-07.-2005, 08:30 AM   #49
homeycheese
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Downtown in the ATL
Posts: 183
Default Re: Zabriskie is a disgrace to Americans in the international peleton

Quote:
Originally Posted by rejobako
Paul Sherwan offered similar (not quite so damning) sentiments, saying that he thought it would have been appropriate for at least one or two of his CSC teammates to hang back and shepherd DZ home.

But it's awfully easy to second-guess in this kind of situation, when in real time the decision needed to be made without hesitation. The reports I heard were that Riis and his team discussed what to do if DZ had a problem late in the stage, and the decision was to leave him and go for the sponsor's main goal of winning the TTT and also to minimize any GC impact on Basso. When the incident happened, CSC could, in theory, have pre-assigned a couple of riders to stay with DZ and send the rest to the line, but they would have had to be doubly sure they had the minimum 5 riders get to the line to stop the clock. Given the stress and excitement of that unfortunate moment, it seems unfair to condemn Riis and his team so harshly.

The facts make it fair to criticize. My judgement is based on actions and results and clearly Riis owns the responsibilty for the actions of the team in this instance.

When you look at the totallity of his public comments and actions over the past few years, it is clear that Riis puts his own ego ahead of all other things and failed to create real leadership on that team.

The "win at all costs" approach exhibited in the TTT is a clear indication of a weak management style and coupled with his public criticisms of his riders in the past indicates a lack of respect for the race and his riders.

I know the culture of the CSC organization and that's not what they are about....

DZ deserves better.
homeycheese is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 08-07.-2005, 12:09 PM   #50
davidbod
Registered User
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Houston, TX
Posts: 712
Default Re: Zabriskie is a disgrace to Americans in the international peleton

What if CSC had beaten DC by 2 seconds, what would the talk of tactics be then?
davidbod is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 11-07.-2005, 09:20 PM   #51
musette
Registered User
 
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,405
Default Re: Zabriskie is a disgrace to Americans in the international peleton

Riis was right in not waiting, and not allocating any riders to help, DZ. The following are the reasons:

-- Riis knew DC was behind CSC by fewer and fewer seconds as the end of the stage drew near. He knew, and it was obvious, that a very few seconds would separate DC and CSC in the end. He also knew that the end was quite tricky, and that DC had all nine men intact. He also knew that his team had already lost a bit of momentum from Rich and Basso (and other CSC cyclists) having to react to DZ's fall.

-- Riis and the whole team had agreed that after the 40 km mark in the stage, only Basso would be waited for. DZ knew this. Evidence of this is that Carlos Sastre, who is the "backup" GC candidate, lost time relative to CSC on this stage.

-- Most crucially, CSC was trying to position Basso to lose as little time as possible (or to gain time) on LA, even if it was a bit. So the goal of "everybody riding for Basso" was best met by not having anybody wait for DZ.

-- CSC had trained hard to win the TTT. By not waiting for DZ, they were also seeking to preserve the possibility of a TTT win. A TTT win was something that they had made other sacrifices for, including leaving Jacob Phil (spelling) off the team in favor of a stronger TTTist.

-- At the time DZ went down, nobody knew how badly DZ was hurt. If he was badly hurt, he might not have been able to continue anyhow and it would have been pointless for anybody to wait for him.
musette is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 12-07.-2005, 01:42 AM   #52
musette
Registered User
 
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,405
Default Re: Zabriskie is a disgrace to Americans in the international peleton

Other reasons CSC was right in not waiting for DZ:

-- There is no obligation for a yellow jersey wearer to defend his jersey, or his team to do it, if the person or the team doesn't want to. See Voeckler situation from USPS perspective, from last year.

-- Waiting for DZ would have entailed people either stopping or losing considerable amounts of speed for him, and would have probably cost DZ the yellow jersey even if DZ finished with CSC. Given the small time differences separating DC and CSC in the previous time check, it was likely that DZ would have lost by more than 2 seconds to LA and would have lost the yellow jersey anyhow. That's because (1) after the fall, DZ would have been traumatized and wouldn't have been much help to the speed of the team, and (2) CSC would have had to stop or significantly slow down to wait for him.

-- By stopping or slowing, given the more tricky (relative to other parts of the course) of the final portions of the course and the proximity of the CSC riders, CSC risked other riders falling or being dropped. Or risked at a minimum a loss in the line of the cyclists that is best tailored to a speedy finish.
musette is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 12-07.-2005, 02:40 AM   #53
House
Banned
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 860
Default Re: Zabriskie is a disgrace to Americans in the international peleton

A few things I find humorous about this thread:

1) When Chechu was in yellow and went back for bottles for the team all hell broke loose that Lance and USPS didn't respect the yellow jersey. While the reasoning for leaving DZ is sound, it is a bit hypocritical for the same things not to be said.

2) I like how the people who are ripping Lance have completely ignored the comments about different eras in their arguments. It's easy to argue your point if you ignore evidence that doesn't support it.

3) What a complete wank job it is to have someone respond to you and then respond by saying they obviously have only followed the Tour for a few years instead of being a man and stepping up to actually respond.
House is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 12-07.-2005, 04:31 AM   #54
Crankster
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 96
Default Re: Zabriskie is a disgrace to Americans in the international peleton

Quote:
Originally Posted by mitosis
To Captain crankster and Injury,
This discussion has been wrung out on another thread.

http://www.cyclingforums.com/t241449-.html

You sound like you've been following LeTour for a few years at the most.

Read the posts on that thread before you start dashing out your uninformed ideas because all this has shown is how little you know about cycling.

Mitosis:
translation: "I cannot counter your arguments so I will forward you to another thread and insult your knowledge of cycling because, uhmmm, I am the demi-god of armchair TourDeFrance and anyone who disagrees with me must be an idiot!".

I don't know you and will not judge your knowledge of the subject, but your debating and logic skills tell me a lot about the kind of person you are.
Crankster is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 12-07.-2005, 01:14 PM   #55
musette
Registered User
 
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,405
Default Re: Zabriskie is a disgrace to Americans in the international peleton

Quote:
Originally Posted by House
A few things I find humorous about this thread:

1) When Chechu was in yellow and went back for bottles for the team all hell broke loose that Lance and USPS didn't respect the yellow jersey. While the reasoning for leaving DZ is sound, it is a bit hypocritical for the same things not to be said.


Things I find humorous -- Chechu is not the same as Victor Hugo Pena, who did wear the maillot jaune. I don't recall Chechu having ever worn the TdF maillot jaune. I could be proven wrong, of course, but I doubt it.

What's so strange about VHP going back for waterbottles in 2003? He was clearly declining in Bruyneel's favor, as evident from his not even making the USPS TdF team in 2004 and his having gotten his salary cut relative to the time when he first joined USPS by Bruyneel.
musette is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 12-07.-2005, 01:38 PM   #56
drebro
Registered User
 
drebro's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Columbia, South Carolina, United States
Posts: 36
Default Re: Zabriskie is a disgrace to Americans in the international peleton

Quote:
Originally Posted by Banesto2007
Youre smug and gay with all of your little smiley faces. You dont understand on-the-road tactics and I shouldnt have place any importance on quoted sources. An Anglo correspondant for an Anglo publication/site, regarding an Anglo rider on an Anglo team. Enough said. Its a Latin sport with Latin ethics. Yall are outsiders. This isnt gay ass, ball busting Paris Roubaix where everyone rides for themselves, destroying their nuts over cobbles. Ok , first of all CSC is overrated. Riis isnt a great strategist, he just had a flukish plan to change tempos on Indurain in the mountains to win in 1996. He took his earnings and secured a sponsor. If Basso's objective was to do well at the Giro, how does Zabriskie expending his reserves on a selfish ITT effort benefit him. Ill repeat again the fact that Riis bitched them all out for losing contact with Basso when he lost :30 on stage 3 and it wasnt even mountainous. Its easy to win an ITT when everyone else is much more tired because they have a job to do on all the other stages. You quoted Zabriskie ..."I WANTED TO WIN TODAY" and from your propaganda filled sources thats all that can be verified. IF Riis wanted him to try and win , thats a horrible tactic because Basso doesnt need the 150th riders' time splits.... (Dave) , when he himself is 6th from last to go. Zabriskie should have conserved for the race itself. Now, Danielson and Zabriskie both are EXTREMELY limited as cyclists. Neither have any muscle mass and the only reason Danielson has shown potential is because hes lived for years at altitude in Durango, CO. and raced against Crit. oriented riders who are only good at riding for an hour or two . He cant go longer than 7-8 days , hes just flat out not an athlete. Zabriskie is 5'11 150 , hell never do well in the tour because he cannot climb with that undersized frame. I wouldnt even consider him to be a good TTT specialist because at his waifish size he doesnt provide much of a draft unless hes got a small guy behind him, for Basso hes comporable but they wont be a good TTT team even with Voigt, Julich. Basso is not even a great athlete even without mentioning the fact that he has no intensity. Fassa Non-Tendered him because he was overrated. Basically the amateurish Riis has been signing everyone elses garbage. Hamilton,Julich,Basso,Voigt Jaksche,Sastre. Theyve dominated Paris-Nice, Tour Med, Crit Int., and Romandie but that is their niche. Bassos podium was a fluke because Jan caught a virus from his kid, and because everyone dropped out. Ullrich, Vino, Lance, Ekimov, Popo, Azevedo, Rubiera, Savoldelli, Cioni, Flecha, Pettachi, Pozzato, Velo, Brusegin , Cancellara , Kirchen , Frigo. Even Sevilla knows what his role is. All of those guys are real riders so that is why Zabriskie, Julich,Hamilton,Landis,Danielson and Basso were all disposed of by those teams. Botero will do better than Landis in July for the Phonak squad. Americans are overrated because they only ride for themselves. They all should go to CSC. Then they can go win all the races in March when its snowing out. Their victories in Romandie were with a blood doping Hamilton.

OH yeah, Tour of Georgia is a gay EXHIBITION race for Americans. Its not even a real race. Why do you think CSC always tries to do well there with Voigt last year and Julich, and Vandborg this year. There werent even time bonuses going into the last day when Danielson only had a 0:04 second lead against Lance,Landis,Julich,Levi, who could all care less about the race. Lance won last year without even trying. Tour of California is going to be a joke too. The only races that matter are
THE TOURS OF FRANCE, SPAIN, ITALY, PARIS-NICE, DAUPHINE-L, LIEGE-B-L, CATALUNYA, PAIS VASCO, VALENCIA, MURCIA, SAN SEBASTIAN, WORLDS, LOMBARDY(unless you dont like racing in October).

WITH THE EXCEPTION OF LIEGE-B-L (which might as well be French), THE SPORT IS IN FRANCE, ITALY, AND SPAIN.

3 Days of De Panne, 4 Days of Dunkirk, Flanders, Roubaix, Fleche Wallone, Amstel, KBK, Camembert, all those others are not meaningful. The races in Switzerland are not great thats why Jan screws up by racing there and Tour of Germany and Italian Criteriums instead of DAUHPINE. At least he did CATALUNYA but he should have tried to win it. CSC is going to implode in Du Tour not DE Tour.

Is this a joke?
drebro is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 12-07.-2005, 10:16 PM   #57
House
Banned
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 860
Default Re: Zabriskie is a disgrace to Americans in the international peleton

Quote:
Originally Posted by musette
Things I find humorous -- Chechu is not the same as Victor Hugo Pena, who did wear the maillot jaune. I don't recall Chechu having ever worn the TdF maillot jaune. I could be proven wrong, of course, but I doubt it.

What's so strange about VHP going back for waterbottles in 2003? He was clearly declining in Bruyneel's favor, as evident from his not even making the USPS TdF team in 2004 and his having gotten his salary cut relative to the time when he first joined USPS by Bruyneel.

Well, shoot! How could I make that mistake?!?!?! But, you get my point.
House is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 31-07.-2005, 01:28 AM   #58
musette
Registered User
 
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,405
Default Re: Zabriskie is a disgrace to Americans in the international peleton

Strange At some point, it's not luck, it's the cyclist contributing to his own problems:

"In a fluke accident after Friday night's criterium in Herning, Denmark, Team CSC's David Zabriskie sustained a deep wound on his right wrist. He was taken to the local hospital, where examinations revealed a damaged nerve in his hand. After a successful surgery at Holstebro Hospital on Saturday morning, Zabriskie now needs to have his hand in a cast for one month, but perhaps he will be able to start training again already after two weeks."

CSC Site
musette is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 31-07.-2005, 06:00 AM   #59
Patrick1983
Registered User
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 63
Default Re: Zabriskie is a disgrace to Americans in the international peleton

Quote:
Originally Posted by Banesto2007
Why did Zabriskie pull the same crap he did at the end of last year when he finished 150th every day for the first 12 days of the Vuelta and then attacked FIVE KILOMETERS into stage 14 or whatever it was. The peleton crashed and the sprinters teams couldnt real him in before the end. Im sure that Zabriskie completely spent all of his domestique energy on the last 20k of that stage. Pettachi, who wanted to win that stage, basically acknoweledged in the least possible manner by saying "Zabriskie certainly rode well , BUT...". If everyone raced in that fashion, there would be no team concept. Most guys in the bottom 50 of the GC could win stages but they are there to work for their teamleaders. Maybe FLoyd Landis would have held the Overall Leaders Jersey in the Vuelta last year if he had the help of coheisive teammates. For all of the people who are scratching their heads as to why US Postal Service non-tendered (no contract offer) Zabriskie , it was exactly for this reason. Bjarn Riis doesnt care about this stuff though because he just wants Anglos and English speakers on his team. Plus he wants any publicity he can get. Its this same attitude that had half of the sport suspecting that he DOPED to enable himself to deny the great, Miguel Indurain, his 6 TDF in succession. That basically ended Migs career permaturely.
Back to the point. Zabriskie was supposed to be working for Basso , and he did well for him in the mountains and in the first week, but he could have been responsible for Basso not having the morale to recover on the bad days. First of all 3 days into the race , Riis had to take corrective measures to get David to protect Ivan. Then a few days later Zabriskie went 120% on the first ITT and ended up finishing 1) Zabriskie 2)Basso. Basso should have won 3 stages in the 2005 Giro D' Italia if it werent for his traitor leuitenant. This just shows how the UCI system is so flawed because the Pro Tour only rewards this type of selfishness with 3 Points in a 3 Week Tour. Unless someone is a pure sprinter going for Points Jersey they should be working for the GC either for themselves or for their teamleader. Also Zabriskie blowing off an interview with Phil Liggett and not even wearing his Stars and Stripes Jersey as National Time Trial Champion is a disgrace. Americans are outsiders in Europe and we should approach the sport with the Big Picure in mind and not how we can squeeze out maximum exposure for ourselves.

Also its sad that a mediocre sprinter such as Issac Galvez can accure more UCI points for sitting on till the last 10k of the sprint stages, finishing 6th in those stages, compared with someone who can finish in the 1st group , climb and TT their way to a top 15 in the final GC. Im sure Zabriskie got more points than someone like Cauchiolli and that is just wrong.


why is blowing out phil ligget such a bad thing?,
if i was a rider i'd tell him to go F**k himself

he licks the arses off the english speaking riders

phil ligget is the biggest Wan**r in cycling today along with sherwin
the only good guy out of the trio is emlach
Patrick1983 is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 01-08.-2005, 01:38 AM   #60
musette
Registered User
 
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,405
Default Re: Zabriskie is a disgrace to Americans in the international peleton

Quote:
Originally Posted by musette
"US National TT champ Zabriskie showed his tremendous talent as a tester today and followed CSC's Bjarne Riis' plan. Riis had Dave Z ride all-out to put pressure on the other riders and give his team leader Ivan Basso fast time splits to ride against."

http://www.cyclingnews.com/road/200...results/giro058

In the same article, we have further proof in the form of a direct quote from ZABRISKE that Riis allowed him to ride as fast as he could, in part because he could provide splits for Basso:

"Cyclingnews spoke to Zabriskie and asked him his objective in today's time trial stage and he explained, "I wanted to go really fast and win...plus I could give Ivan (Basso) my split times. (Bjarne Riis and CSC d.s. Alain Gallopin) told me to go for it, so I did."


I have been thinking more about why Riis asked Zabriskie to go all out. Here are other possibilities:

-- As everybody knows, Riis was really targeting a win at the Stage 4 TTT. One of the strategic advantages that is important in the TTT is being the last team to leave, so that the team would know all other competitors' split times and adjust accordingly. Riis knew that this, and probably wanted Zabriskie's time in Stage 1 to be included in the top three CSC times for Stage 1 that would largely determine the leading team in the teams competition in Stage 1 (which would likely be the leading team before Stage 4).

-- Riis knows LA is generally a better ITTist than Basso. Therefore, there was a chance that Zabriskie, if he held back, would have been second to LA and not to Basso. That would have deprived Zabriskie of a win not over Basso, but over CSC rival LA. Same for JU, because nobody really knew the extent of the impact of the crash into Kummer's car the prior day.
musette is offline  
Reply With Quote

Reply


Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump



All times are GMT +10. The time now is 06:38 PM.


Powered by: vBulletin Copyright © 2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2001 - 2006 cyclingforums.com

Links to websites we like:
Pezcyclingnews | Cyclingnews.com | Wine Zone | iinet